2017: A Look Back In Horror – The Worst In Wrestling!

82 Submitted by on Thu, 28 December 2017, 20:00

Greetings, all. Hope you had a lovely Christmas, or whatever you may celebrate.

This is my fifth year in a row writing this list for WrestleCrap, and I consider the final product a pretty fair (albeit subjective) barometer of what was bad in wrestling throughout 2017. Some items were, “Bad, but I smiled.” Others were, “Bad, and I shook my head.” And a few were, “Bad, but I pretended to like it for the simple thrill of demonstrative irony.”

Therein lies the essence of the list that I try to create each year: a variety of bad things, with different shades of badness represented – some loathsome, some harmless. You will agree with quite a few items on here, I’m certain. Others you will likely disagree with vehemently. I can sense right now that #34 will be a divisive one, but I won’t budge on it. Hence the prior use of the word, “subjective”.

For 2017, I decided to alter my scope a bit, out of necessity. In previous years of doing this list, I had a tendency to include news stories that were negative, like somebody going to jail, or somebody failing a drug test, or what have you. With the benefit of hindsight, I find that including such items only made the list less fun. I’d rather just mock goofy junk, you know? I mean, had I done this list for 1993, it’d hardly be fair to equate the BS ending of WrestleMania 9 with Sid Vicious nearly stabbing Arn Anderson to death.

It’d be hard to laugh at the silliness of 2017 if I included Sexy Star breaking Rosemary’s arm, or the allegations of JBL’s backstage bullying. Is Rosemary having her arm broken worse than a ridiculous “match” inside an abandoned farmhouse? You see the needless dilemma, surely.

So for 2017, and going forward, I intend to keep the list as light-hearted as the spirit of WrestleCrap itself. What you’ll find on this year’s list are items that could potentially be worked into future inductions here at the site. Not all fifty entries will meet this precise criteria, but a pretty good number of them do. For the most part, the entries ahead met the basic criteria of, “Can we playfully mock it, without it triggering our most righteous of anger?” I feel this is the important distinction that needs to be made.

Besides, there was plenty in 2017 that could be mocked, without having to hit up the newz-sites for, as Bruce Prichard would say, “rumor and innuendo.” The TV product gave us enough technicolor drek this year.

To be fair, 2017 wasn’t all bad. WrestleMania 33, while still interminably long, was much better than last year’s show. New Japan continues churning out great shows, and has me positively hooked on the forthcoming Kenny Omega/Chris Jericho showdown. AJ Styles reigns once more as WWE Champion, after a year of the belt being relegated to some truly awful angles. Wrestlers like Cody Rhodes and The Young Bucks prove that you can make a good living in the business without WWE signing your checks, opening the door for more viable wrestling away from the Stamford shadow. Podcasts like those of Jericho’s, Jim Cornette’s, Bruce Prichard’s, Tony Schiavone’s, and more offer tremendous insight into the business, as well as a number of honest-to-goodness laughs. Pete Dunne and Tyler Bate put on a true classic at the Chicago TakeOver, melding modern-day complex grappling with subtle pathos and selling. Braun Strowman became a legitimate main event monster through large-scale destruction, and a strong undercurrent of well-projected gravitas.

On the flip side, there was a whole lotta crap to be shoveled. And shovel it I did.

Any comments, questions, criticisms, and creative insults, please direct them to my Twitter, where I am apt to respond. I treat others the way I am treated, so as long as you are respectful, I shall respond in kind.

And a special thanks to RD Reynolds, Art O’Donnell, and Maffew Gregg each for reading off my tentative rankings for this list, and inspiring me with items I may have left out. Their patience and help is always appreciated.

And yes, RD will be announcing the final 10 Gooker nominees here at WrestleCrap during the first week of 2018. So be sure to come back and vote for what you think was the very worst of the very worst!

With all that said…away we go.


50. John Cena is magically a free agent

A year into the new brand split, and miraculously, John Cena was the only wrestler (out of like 60 or 70) whose brand-exclusive contract expires when it does. The blue-brander is granted the autonomy to go to whichever show he chooses, conveniently at a point when Raw, whose ratings are nearing record lows, could use a star like Cena to boost ’em. As the Church Lady would say, “How conveeeeeeenient.”

49. Cena’s pre-Battleground promo

It’s hard to imagine a day where patriotism and “foreign heels” are no longer tropes in wrestling, but they do feel a bit out of place as WWE becomes even more of a multicultural and multi-national organization. John Cena playing the 9/11 card in order to build up a middling, throwaway flag match with water-treading Rusev this past July felt like an odd juxtaposition

48. TNA airs wrong Impact in Canada

It seems like Impact Wrestling just can’t win. There are enough LOLTNA gaffes to write a 1400-page book on (RD, Bryan, I’m game – you know how to reach me), and moments like this just don’t help. Somehow, someway, Canada’s Fight Network aired the wrong episode of Impact on the night of January 12. And who owns The Fight Network? Anthem Sports, who also owns Impact Wrestling. That’s a bit troubling.

47. Kalisto’s short ride

Tipping the ambulance over with Roman Reigns inside, and then breaking the ring by superplexing Big Show. If Braun Strowman were Francis Ford Coppola, those would be his Godfather I and Godfather II. By comparison, that makes him pushing Kalisto off of a two foot stage in a teeny-tiny dumpster Godfather III. Or maybe even Twixt.

46. Did he give it six stars, or was it only five?

So Dave Meltzer, connoisseur of the pro wrestling star-rating system, goes beyond the agreed-upon five-star max to give Kazuchika Okada and Kenny Omega six stars for their WrestleKingdom match, followed by six-and-one-quarter stars for their rematch at Dominion. This sparks a very real debate internet-wide about whether or not those HIGHLY SUBJECTIVE ratings should be accepted by fans as legitimate, as I pray for a meteor.

45. The Bludgeon Brothers’ outfits

Two towering bad asses that look scary? Check. A team name that sounds tough, and isn’t just some lazy combination of both men’s names? Check. Intimidating theme music? Check. Costumes that compliment the wrestlers’ appearances, team name, and music? Well, not quite. Maybe Harper and Rowan should just borrow The Ascension’s gear instead of looking like they’re wearing Kane’s pajamas.

44. Slater and Hawkins: We’ll entertain you, while somebody is dying

Okay, so Roman Reigns has just slaughtered Braun Strowman in the parking lot in cold blood. Strowman is trapped in a vehicle and possibly bleeding to death. What does WWE do? They send Curt Hawkins and Heath Slater out for a match that the home audience barely sees, because they (and the fans in the arena, come to think of it) are pre-occupied with Strowman’s predicament. What are they, rodeo clowns?

43. The unimaginative Superstar shake-up

Remember the WWE drafts of yore, when Raw and SmackDown‘s rosters would be set up in two separate locker rooms, and there would be high drama whenever a name would get called? WWE decided that was too much fun, and kinda just half-assed their way through the “Superstar Shake-up” Basically, it was just a huge trade with details gradually revealed, at their leisure. Riveting.

42. Blocking the Gronky Punch

WWE had their SportsCenter moment all lined up on the WrestleMania 33 pre-show, with Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski hanging out front row during the Andre the Giant battle royal. Gronk, a legitimate friend of Mojo Rawley’s, jumped the rail in order to defend his buddy, when a female security guard (who was never “smartened up”) moved to detain him. Guess she’d never seen a box of Gronk Flakes before.

41. Carmella vs. CJ Lunde

The match was sloppy enough with a badly-blown finish, but made all the more irksome by JBL (and even Byron Saxton) ragging on the attire and appearance of enhancement talent Lunde. Lunde is known better as indy wrestler Thunderkitty, and dresses like an old-timey female grappler, which gave JBL the opening to spend the entire match bashing her. Or perhaps he was just speaking for the man in his headset.

40. Poundin’ that poultry, with Enzo Amore

Enzo Amore is many things to many people. To his fans, he’s as creative a wordsmith as there is. To his detractors, he’s obnoxious. To many in the locker room (allegedly), he’s an annoyance. He’s apparently an alektorophiliac as well, given the KFC Georgia Gold spot in which Enzo tries to put the moves on some admittedly-yummy honey mustard chicken. Wonder how Colonel Norm MacDonald would’ve played that script?

39. The Dashabot 2000

There are wooden, lifeless backstage interviewers, and then there’s Dasha Fuentes, who speaks with the impeccable smoothness of a Speak ‘n Spell being waterboarded. It’s unclear why WWE insists on having interchangeably-sterile interviewers, but it really does make one miss the days of a consummate pro like Mean Gene. At least WWE Studios could use Dasha to make a feature film version of Small Wonder.

38. Lawler has a “heart attack”, and JBL falls down

Jerry Lawler’s on-air heart attack in 2012 was partially facilitated by wrestling (at age 62) in a tag match earlier that night, with Dolph Ziggler on the opposing team. That fact was brought up during a needless January “King’s Court” segment with Ziggler, which ended with Dolph kicking him in the torso, and Lawler selling like he’d had another heart attack. Oh, and JBL fell on his ass.


Seth Rollins’ theme music is a bit quirky – just three sections of amped up hard rock separated by pronounced pauses. Someone in WWE apparently didn’t care for the pauses, and the song was “improved” by some screamo-type shouting “burn it down” (the audio equivalent of having a cordless drill shoved in one’s ear) over the first pause. The phrase begs the question of why an architect would want to commit arson. Sounds counterproductive.

36. Bound For Glory 2017

Given the myriad of changes and difficulties the promotion has had in 2017, it’s no surprise that Bound For Glory was as lackluster as it was. Between Alberto El Patron’s uncomfortable promo (that was edited off of later airings), flat wrestling, and interference-laden booking, it seemed as though Impact Wrestling was apt to continue its struggles by airing a show that couldn’t help their cause.

35. Goldberg vs. Kevin Owens

Some of Goldberg’s best matches are short – his WrestleMania 33 bout with Brock Lesnar is one of my favorite matches of 2017, truth be told. However, his grueling slugfest with Kevin Owens at Fastlane, all 20 seconds of it, didn’t exactly satisfy many that watched it. There was no reason for high expectations anyway, but surely WWE could have announced a five-minute time limit ahead of time, or something.

34. “The Bar”

Nothing wrong with the hard-hitting duo of Sheamus and Cesaro as a team, aside from their name. In kayfabe, it sounds like the towering twosome were wracking their brains trying to come up with a dual moniker, and were on the verge of giving up. Then suddenly, a Ford F-150 commercial with Denis Leary’s surly voiceover played on the TV. “It is ‘the bar’? WE are the bar!”, they cried, before sharing a high-five.

33. Great Balls of Fire – the name

If nothing else, naming a pay-per-view after Jerry Lee Lewis’ signature hit opened up the floodgates of mockery – everyone on social media had a requisite, “What’s WWE’s next pay-per-view, _____________?” antiquated song title-joke to follow. If that weren’t enough, the original logo had a rather phallical shape to it, needing just four wheels to match Ace and Gary’s crime-fighting ride.

32. Alicia Fox: Facetime Distraction

There was once a match on the old NXT, where Kaitlyn faced Maxine, all the while their mentors (Alicia Fox and Vickie Guerrero) shouted instructions over body mics. It was as bad as it sounds. In 2017, WWE gave us a mini-sequel by having Alicia Fox harass boyfriend Noam Dar over Facetime (conveniently played over the Titan Tron), causing him to lose to Cedric Alexander. A waste of both airtime and data.

31. Who wants to throw veggies….at Elias?

Interrupting Elias when he’s at peak pretentiousness sounds like a good way for a babyface to shine. Leave it to WWE, of course, to overthink things by having human tundra Jason Jordan arrive with a shopping cart filled with produce, all for flinging at WWE’s drifter. Then to kill time, he did it again later. Worth asking if Jordan wore just his ring trunks when he stopped by Whole Foods that day.

30. Sarah Logan’s “game meat” promo

At first it was difficult to understand Miss Logan’s unfortunate promo, since she spoke with a put-on southern accent that was thicker than Buff Bagwell’s calf implants. She apparently said “game meat”, but many heard “gay meat”, giving the awkward moment a hook from which to hang it in place forever. Just resign yourself to the fact that she’ll be wearing bib overalls by March.

29. Shane McMahon in 2017, period

Whether he’s refusing medical help after being thrown through a car window, or warring for 40 monotonous minutes in a Hell in a Cell match, seeing 47-year-old Shane McMahon stand toe-to-toe (or rather, tucked pantleg-to-toe) with SmackDown‘s top stars feels awfully anachronistic. Credit to the man for taking the risks that he does, but the thrill is gone.

28. “Roode jumped from NXT to be at GFW”

In September, Impact Wrestling/GFW/NWA-TNA aired a pre-recorded PPV consisting of matches taped for Global Force more than two years earlier, and it just so happened that Bobby Roode (by now on SmackDown Live) was among the yellowed footage. The announcers (in a priceless moment you can hardly be mad at) claimed that Roode made the jump to GFW from WWE/NXT. C’mon, you laughed.

27. Bayley on the main roster

Bayley was once referred to as, “the female John Cena” by a number of viewers, and it was meant as a compliment. Her genuine warmth and innocence melded with her innate ability to play a determined, hard-working underdog, giving NXT audiences (especially kids) a star worth believing in. That was, until Bayley’s mojo was undone by poorly-delivered promos, and segments that undermine what make her special.

26. The women’s Money in the Bank: the aftermath, but also the promotion

Maybe it’s just the old school wrestling fan in me, but when a heel wins a match through nefarious means, it should be taken at face value as “a wicked character gleefully takes a tainted victory.” Of course, maybe WWE shouldn’t have back-patted themselves for promoting the match as an historic first for women wrestlers, painting themselves as benevolent forward-thinkers. That kinda set the bar of expectations high, didn’t it?

25. The Anthem Owl

“And fuck that owl”, said Reby Hardy, of the Impact Wrestling strigidae that ranks with other tedious wrestling mascots like The Gobbledy Gooker, Wild Cat Willie, and Todd Pettengill. For some reason, Anthem Sports and Entertainment chose to make the creature in their logo a highly-visible part of weekly Impact programming, when a better use of the owl would’ve been to upgrade the pre-existing commentary by giving it a headset.

24. Fans yelling “TEN”, “ONE FALL”, and “1-2-SWEEEEET”

Not only does wrestling have its own version of “PLAY FREE BIRD”, but it has several, and each of them are just as fresh and witty as the decades-old Skynyrd gag. Overnight, wrestling seemingly became The Rocky Horror Picture Show, complete with devotees yelling the same mocking phrases at show after show. Thing is, with Rocky Horror, the mocking phrases actually do make the show better.

23. Beach balls

I can’t imagine why WWE doesn’t take its most vocal audience members seriously. You know, the ones who want Cesaro to be WWE Champion, and vocalize said desires, then take to batting around inflatable toys when he’s in the midst of an important pay-per-view match, with gold and pride at stake. It’s a mystery, for sure.


Alicia used the money she earned from her time as a home-wrecking wedding planner to pay her way through the Tommy Wiseau School of Acting. Not that there are many true thespians on WWE’s roster (we’ll never know with the corny scripts they’re handed), but Alicia’s hammy overacting after being dumped by Cedric Alexander made Nicolas Cage go, “Geez, pull it back a skosh.”

21. What’s TNA’s name this week?

Truly the Ed Leslie of wrestling promotions, the former TNA had experienced something of an identity crisis in 2017. In March, they became “Impact Wrestling”, before attempting to re-brand as Global Force Wrestling in June. By autumn, after a falling out with Jeff Jarrett, they were back to being Impact Wrestling once more, and maintained custody of the owl.

20. Big Cass vs. Big Show, Shark Cage Match

The crowd just didn’t care one bit about Big Show and his injured hand, nor about heel Cass, whose selling point was, “HE’S BIG AND TALL AND INTENSE, PAL!”. Putting Enzo in the shark cage (where heel managers go) only distracted from what was already a molasses-slow borefest. Even Enzo creatively escaping the cage was pointless, since he was booted down immediately.

19. Mickie is “old”

Sexually-ambiguous stalking of Trish Stratus aside, what was Mickie James’ best WWE angle? Has she even had another good one? By default, her sterile existence as “smiling babyface Diva #6,385” from 2006 to 2010 surely trumps “Piggy James”, and certainly, “Hey Mickie, you’re old!” At 38, Mickie is barely older than Asuka. Surprising that WWE didn’t inflate the number and try to claim that Mickie is 54, “for entertainment purposes.” They do that.

18. Under Siege

It’s strange how Raw and SmackDown can live in some state of detente for 11 months out of the year, before something in the October sky drives them toward unquenchable hatred toward the other brand. The most peaceable of the SmackDown brand were suddenly driven to kill all things red, while standing among the inter-brand mortal enemies they made throughout the year.

17. “I hear voices in my head, they ordered me, to torch your shed.”

Not only does Randy Orton’s box of Cuban cigars burn down Susan Ross’ father’s cabin, but he seems awful defiant about the property damage. “The Viper” not only demonstrates a complete lack of remorse or empathy for the eradication of some dead nun’s spirit, but when he films the preamble to the fire, it’s done with weird vignetted camera cuts, like something out of mid-90s MTV.

16. Fastlane 2017

It was the best non-WrestleMania March pay-per-view in WWE history, which is to say it was the only one. And it’d be the worst one, even if Great American Bash 1991 were held in March 2017. Goldberg/Owens aside, the undercard was one eight-minute slog after another, be it Cesaro/Mahal, Big Show/Rusev, or Sasha/Nia. Fastlane felt more like a 29-car funeral procession.

15. Cena points out all of Roman’s flaws

Late this past summer, WWE stuck Reigns into a short feud with Cena, who proceeds to deliver worked-shoot tirades on Reigns. Cena accused him of being Cena-lite, of not being able to cut quality promos, and noted that he failed a drug test. Given WWE’s Captain Ahab-like stubbornness regarding the Reigns uber-push, it’s a bit odd to see them say, “Yeah, we agree, he’s mightily flawed,” then push him anyway.

14. The sudden push of Jinder Mahal

From a business standpoint, it made sense – India has a population of 1.3 billion people, and it’s a fertile market for a professional wrestling empire to try and make a sizable splash in. But pushing Mahal to the title was the same as putting the WWE Championship on long-time undercarder SD Jones in 1986, had WWE just received broadcasting clearance in Antigua. Not that Mahal moved numbers, anyway.

13. Battleground 2017

When WWE split their rosters once more in 2016, cynics like myself forecasted that it wouldn’t be long before SmackDown returned to its previous role of disrespected whore sister of the family. I can’t say for sure that Battleground was the precise moment that the reversion became official, but an interminable Punjabi Prison match and the world’s slowest flag match likely aided it.

12. Ziggler rips off everyone’s entrance

Ziggler’s stated beef was that fans seemed care more for elaborate entrances than the ostensible reason that wrestlers gather at the arena (to fight), so he began ripping off the entrances of others for cheap heat. Nothing says, “He’s stuck in the midcard and we have nothing for him,” like ill-mannered, irreverent gimmick infringement that drags on week after week.

11. Brian Kendrick vs. Jack Gallagher

I’m willing to bet that some perpetual optimists out there thought that 205 Live would be a no-frills cruiserweight extravaganza, presented with the dignity of the Cruiserweight Classic. Instead, you get Brian Kendrick’s elementary mockery of Jack Gallagher, either by dressing as him, or doctoring a photo of him so that he looked like a clown, and so forth. Couldn’t have enough clown references, after all.

10. Alexa Bliss vs. Bayley, Kendo Stick Match

Whenever a well-regarded wrestler loses in less-than-optimum fashion, annoyed fans will say that they were “buried”, which is rarely true. On the contrary, Bayley was BURIED in the Kendo Stick match against Bliss at Extreme Rules. What was once a promising, beloved character was creatively unraveled throughout April and May before looking like, as Bryan Alvarez would opine, “an utter geek” in the loss to Bliss.

9. Josh Mathews vs. Jeremy Borash

Remember how great Monday Night RAW was when Michael Cole played an obnoxious heel, and defecated all over anything and everything that wasn’t The Miz? Well, okay, it wasn’t great, and it in fact detracted from the show. For some reason, Impact Wrestling got it into their heads to recreate that acrimony by having Mathews and Borash hijack the shows with grating, passive-aggressive arguing for two hours.

8. Jason Jordan is Kurt Angle’s son

There’s still the very real (and very likely) possibility that Jordan turns heel to match the negative reception he receives (Rocky Maivia Mark II, minus the once-in-a-generation charisma), but the build to the revelation promised far more. Between Kurt Angle’s nervousness, and Corey Graves having the juicy inside knowledge of an apparently dire scenario, the grand reveal deserved better than Shelton Cardboardjamin.

7. Finn Balor vs. Bray Wyatt, featuring Sister Abigail

The involvement of the unseen “Sister Abigail” has been a point of interest for many fans, with diminishing returns as the years tick by. Earlier in the fall, any remaining excitement over Wyatt’s purported mentor were dashed for good when Wyatt used his magic powers to “morph” into the wisened nun. Suddenly, the revelation that Hornswoggle was the anonymous Raw GM looked comparatively brilliant.

6. Superimposed bugs

As Bart Simpson noted, there’s nothing scarier than going to school. Bray Wyatt concurs, which is why at WrestleMania 33, he summoned insect-related film strips from his father’s elementary school science classes as part of some shrewd plan to intimidate Randy Orton. It really speaks to the awfulness of SmackDown in 2017 that Orton has two entries on this list worse than writhing stock footage.

5. Punjabi Prison Match

The visibility-blocking cylinders known as the Punjabi Prison were dusted off for Battleground in Philadelphia, because if there’s one thing every wrestler that’s billed from India knows, it’s the ins and outs of a Punjabi Prison. The only thing stopping the entire crowd from unanimously booing the match is that many fans left their seats during the bout to purchase Royal Rumble tickets at the box office.

4. Emmalina

I like the name “Emmalina” because it rhymes with semolina, which is a delicious bread that goes with any pasta dinner. Unlike semolina bread, Emmalina provided no such nourishment, as the strained hype train dragged on longer than most dictatorships. When Emmalina (long since acknowledged as a company-endorsed running joke) finally emerged, she disappeared again to reverse her makeover. Hey, did you know that Raw hasn’t had a 3.0 rating since March 2015?

3. Lavar Ball segment

Not content to just pollute ESPN and social media with his self-promotion and his eye-rolling claims, Lavar Ball brought sons Lonzo and LaMelo to Monday Night RAW, all but assuring a train wreck. Indeed, after the elder Ball’s ring entry struggles, his refusal to follow a script, and LaMelo’s shouts of a rather bad word, the family was asked to leave the building. If only WWE had done that much sooner.

2. This Is Your Life, Bayley

Booker T plainly stated, “This is hard to watch”, and he wasn’t wrong. In a showcase way too elaborate and tedious for its own good, Alexa Bliss embarrassed poor Bayley with artifacts and figures of Bayley’s past, while the crowd turned on the segment with more ferocity than any heel that Sting trusts. WWE even acknowledged the segment’s badness the following week, with Alexa having to field the on-camera blame.

1. House of Horrors

There’s a reason why our pal RD was compelled to induct it mere days after it happened. There’s absurdity, there’s “thinking outside the box”, and then there’s hit-or-miss theatricality that does nothing but miss. Between dolls hanging from the ceiling, announcers deftly segueing into the next match (despite Orton lying dead beneath a fridge), and the harsh response from the San Jose crowd, it’s no wonder Mr. Reynolds got to work immediately.

Written by

Justin Henry is WrestleCrap's inquiring newsman, thirsting for knowledge always. He enjoys the art of satire, as you'll find in many of his works here at WrestleCrap. Drop him a line on Facebook (http://www.facebook.com/notoriousjrh) and Twitter (http://www.twitter.com/jrhwriting)
82 Responses to "2017: A Look Back In Horror – The Worst In Wrestling!"
  1. "The Big Cheese" Paul Kraft says:

    Wow! Nicely done, Justin!

  2. Dan Sheldon says:

    Definitely #24. You forgot to mention after chanting “1, 2-SWEEEEEET” you will hear all the fans giggling like little schoolgirls at how delightfully funny the chant is. Add to the list of chants “This is awesome” which at one time meant something. Now it’s used so much it completely lost any meaning.

  3. Arya Witner says:

    A couple weeks later I went to SmackDown in Boston. After SD ended and thousands of people ran for the exits, I ran to try to get better seats for 205 Live. I got one section over and was going for the hard camera seats when that same female security guard that stopped Gronk literally stepped in front of me and refused to let me move any further, even though there were rows and rows of empty seats that other people were running to.

  4. Christopher Olsen says:

    Nice work! As a side note, I cannot stand Reby Hardy, but “F@ck that owl” was legitimately hilarious.

  5. Autrach Sejanoz says:

    Had to laugh at “I hear voices in my head, they ordered me, to torch your shed.” Nice work, Justin!

  6. Chris V says:

    It was a really bad year for Bray Wyatt and Bayley….
    A great portion of the entire list was nearly taken up with bad angles involving Wyatt or Bayley being completely ruined as characters.

    • dennett316 says:

      The best thing that happened to Wyatt this year was a bout of a viral illness that stopped the Sister Abigail match from happening. It’d have been one goofy-ass mess too far, his career would’ve been tanked right then.
      I just don’t get how they messed the Wyatt Family up so badly…they should’ve been monster heels for years to come.

      • Hulk6785 says:

        He should have been the next Undertaker only without all the mistakes they made with Taker in his early days (Taker VS Taker, that Casket Match, the slow wrestling style he had), but they have just completely fucked him over by booking him in shit that is even worse than the crap they put Taker through. It is maddening to see how badly they have screwed the pooch with Bray Wyatt.

  7. Alexandru says:

    Thre’s 3 things guaranteed in life death, taxes, and Fastlane is always awful

  8. MikEnigma says:

    ……………………….So are we not having a Gooker vote this year?

  9. TK says:

    It’s a fine piece every year and it’s understandable it can be a tough list especially this year. I am a bit surprised the whole lawsuit over the “Too Sweet” hand gesture/Jimmy Jacobs firing wasn’t on the list, but looking what is on it, rankings aside, it was already hard to keep it to just 50. Somehow reading Orton hearing voices in his head to torch a shed, maybe he just had Seth Rollins’ Burn It Down” theme song on his iPod all this time. Keep up the fine work and that goes the same for the entire Wrestlecrap crew!

  10. Raging_Demons says:

    2017 for WWE’swomen when it comes to “A Women’s First in WWE” expect train wreckage. Not only the Money In The Bank Match was bad anything historic was awful, take the Women’s Hell In A Cell Match; you got Charlotte wrestling super sloppy and she nearly kills (as in live onscreen) Sasha Banks by throwing her to a dropping Hell In A Cell, if the WWE Tech guys didn’t stop the Cell from dropping Sasha would be squashed to death by the Cell and the funny part was that it was in a real close-up shot. I’ve seen Thunderkitty wrestle and she’s not that great but throw her in with Carmella (who wrestles, dresses, and acts like a stripper who drinks WAY too much) and this match was god awful from the beginning, just by adding JBL made this bad to “Kennel From Hell” bad.

    God Alexa Bliss is cringe worthy on so many levels. She appears 3 times on the list which to me shows how god awful she is. Most of WWE’s dislikes Youtube wise were Emiliana vids btw.

    Thanks for the column Justin.

    • Si says:

      Women’s HIAC was 2016.

    • Guest says:

      By that same logic Bayley being on the list means she’s awful as well.

    • C Bos says:

      Creative has given Alexa some awful material but she is the best mic worker in the women’s division and better than most men on the stick (but not quite as good as The Miz). And her in ring work is more than credible. Plus, I do like the talent over size angle she embodies.

      She certainly is the opposite of the charisma vacuum that is Randy Orton who is an outdated stance and nothing more.

      • KatieVictoriasSecret says:

        Agreed, I think the most frustrating thing about that angle is that Bayley and Alexa are talented and booking just handed them a turd too big to polish.

  11. #OPC says:

    March of 2016 featured Road Block.

    I think 51 is the Nia Jax/Enzo stuff, particularly their mistletoe segment.

    As for the Anthem Owl commentating, well, Jim Neidhart would approve for sure.

    And the best part of House of Horrors was when people sent in a screen grab of that image of Orton and Wyatt on the floor, to law enforcement agencies, reporting a drug overdose. Makes you wonder if someone WAS on drugs when they came up with that match.

  12. Chris says:

    What about the “creative” decision to push Brock as a heel in Minnesota in his feud with Goldberg? It backfired so terribly that Vince had to abort the whole segment…shutting off Heyman’s mic and hitting Lesnar’s music mid promo. Cringeworthy.

  13. Si says:

    Good list, but if I’m going to pick holes – and I’m an Internet wrestling fan, it’s my job – wasn’t the point of Slater-Hawkins that it was a match nobody could care about happening which was deliberately used as background to pretend the PPV was still going on but what was happening backstage was kayfabe-unexpected so had to be attended to? Even the pair of them were making knowing jokes about it.

  14. JustAGuyGuy says:

    I know we HAVE to vote technically, but clearly House of Horrors is going to end up lapping the rest of the field next week.

    • Jimbob Jones says:

      That pretty much has to be the winner.

      Of course, there will be one TNA entry that will get way more votes than it rightfully deserves (if you look at this list, even Justin was struggling to add non-WWE stuff, even going to the STATION airing the wrong episode of Impact as somehow being their fault), but I can’t imagine anything but the House of Horrors (or, better yet, the entire Bray/Orton feud. Actually, better yet, let’s just make the entry “Bray Wyatt’s 2017” — it would be FAR funnier) “winning” the Gooker.

  15. Thomas Moffatt says:

    I would have thrown in Roman Reigns as #30 in the Rumble (Done to deliberately piss off the fans) and the non-traditional fans references post WM33 (they pretty much said anyone who didn’t like Roman Reigns doesn’t like WWE). Gooker for me would be Roman Reigns loses cleanly then tries to kill his opponent and is still pushed a face…

    • Justin Henry says:

      I can’t really agree with that, because I enjoyed Austin’s anti-heroism. Babyface trying to kill the heel, fair play or not? Just means he wants it more.

      • Guest says:

        Even more so when the guy the Babyface is trying to kill is someone he has bar blood with.

        It’s like Batman not going after the Joker after Death In The Family

        • Thomas Moffatt says:

          You both make good points and I enjoyed the Austin anti-hero stuff but he fit the role. Roman does not strike me as an anti-hero (yeah, I know he’s part of the Shield but meh) and the angle was perfect for a double turn. Strowman looked the hero emerging from the wreck and staggering off refusing help. Anyway let’s agree to disagree 🙂

          Can I add two things? 1) Mickie James STILL has a great arse and 2) in defence of the superstar shake-up it inadvertently got rid of David Otunga from commentary.

          • Guest says:

            I don’t know about number 1 bro as Bayley’s (and of course Naomi’s) have that category on lock.

            As for number 2 well it helps that Otunga is going through marital issues and custody issues…..but it means in turn we have to listen to Booker T.

    • Si says:

      Reigns in the Rumble was done entirely for the smarks, though – everyone from Meltzer downwards said it was so Orton would be cheered and be set up as the face against Bray when he eliminated Roman.

      • #OPC says:

        But of course, Roman ended up being in the main event anyway, against Taker. Orton and Bray weren’t even the last world title match either, that went to Brock/Goldberg, also the Smackdown women’s title match.

  16. Mister Forth says:

    Numbers 19, 10 & 2 somehow turned me away from Alexa for a good while. #2 even seemed as if the original ending was supposed to be Bayley’s “boyfriend” & “friend” were to have sex in the ring while they both screamed Alexa’s name.

  17. gerard says:

    why are you doing this at all you already posted a story way back in either june or july about how stupid the bray wyatt vs randy orton house of horrors match was!! isn’t that already the gooker winner for 2017???

  18. Captain Obvious says:

    9. Josh Mathews vs. Jeremy Borash

    You say that their constant arguing and bickering over an Impact/GFW Wrestling Show is all bad but at the very least it’s enough to drown out the “nails on a chalkboard” commentating of D’Angelo Dinero. How anyone had the gall to let the former Elijah Burke near an announce table is beyond me.

    • Thomas Moffatt says:

      WWE are doing similar on Smackdown with Graves and Saxton with the latter looking like a dick…

    • Guest says:

      A wise man one said you can’t polish a turd.

      Even if they’re drowning out Elijah Burke how they’re going about is still dumb.

  19. Sean Bateman says:

    The 1-2-SWEEEEET is annoying af. How is kicking out of a two count sweet?

    • Darryl Stewart says:

      In kayfabe, for the wrestler that kicks out, they could be thinking “Sweet, I could still win!”…but I realize that’s really stretching it.

  20. Zeke says:

    My thoughts on some of them:

    46. Meltzer breaking his own rating scale did annoy me. Would it honestly have been that terrible to just give all three of Omega/Okada five stars?

    36. This was just so sad for me. I have stuck with TNA for years, in hopes of they could finally get their glory days of being moderately decent of the late 2000s. But I think this show was when I finally said “I’m done”.

    31. And people wonder why Jason Jordan isn’t liked.

    30. I’m going to be honest, despite the fact that NXT is one of the only WWE shows I watched regularly, I have precisely zero memory of Logan ever being on it. Clearly there is a reason why.

    29. Remember in 2016 when people complimented Smackdown for not being obsessed with Authority Figure shenanigans like Raw was? Things really do change fast don’t they?

    27. Within one year, Bayley has gone from one of my favorite wrestlers to someone I actively dread seeing appear on TV, such a shame.

    24. I don’t mind “Ten” and “One Fall”, but “1-2 Sweet” is annoying as fuck. I couldn’t even watch the entire Mae Young Classic because it was driving me insane.

    23. Pretty much everything wrong with smarky crowds can be summed up with the beachball idiocy. Thank you Ceasro for killing it dead.

    16. Either this event, Bound for Glory, or Triplemania XXV get my vote for worst Pay Per-View of the year.

    12. Just release Ziggler already, I’ve gotten so tired of him.

    10. See #27

    9. On the plus side, Scott Steiner showed up and started doing Scott Steiner things, and I thought the actual match at Slammiversary was enjoyable.

    2. See #27

    17, 7, 6, 1. Since House of Horrors was already made the Gooker, I’m guessing there won’t be a vote this year. However, if there was “All things Bray Wyatt” would get my vote. He had a shit feud with Randy Orton, moved over to Raw, jobbed alot, had an even shitier feud with Finn Balor, got sick, came back, and jobbed some more. The Matt Hardy stuff has been fun so far, but that has mostly been because of Matt, and Wyatt is obviously going to eat another loss to Hardy at this feud’s end.

    • Guest says:

      “31. And people wonder why Jason Jordan isn’t liked.”

      I thought it was because someone had the bright idea to book him in angle that’s utterly awful and wasn’t necessary to push him as a singles wrestler..

  21. John C says:

    Let’s give some more love to superimposed bugs. There’s nothing like the Showcase of The Immortals becoming reduced to a cheesy gimmick. Sure The House of Horrors match is terrible as well but…okay I can’t really finish that sentence but tne goofy looking special effect during Mania is so tacky that it should make everyone’s not see list for 2017.

  22. 314 says:

    Glad someone else saw the Ellsworth briefcase-stealing for what it was: a heel using heel tactics to win. Not the “a MAN won the first ever women’s MITB match” nonsense I kept hearing. ESPECIALLY from feminists, good lord.

    • Si says:

      Isn’t that the exact reason why it’s in the list? If Justin saw it as “just great heeling” he wouldn’t have included it, much less made most of his explanation about how it undermined the company’s message about women – if it hadn’t been re-run someone would have found out and used in in one of those many soft soap interviews Stephanie does on morning shows about how WWE are taking a lead role in truly advancing the cause of women in sports and entertainment alike.

      • Justin Henry says:

        I *did* see it as great heeling. I included it for the outrage and for WWE’s precious stance that they were only going to be undermining. The ending was fine.

    • Guest says:

      Ellsworth helping Carmella win the MITB wouldn’t have been so bad if of course WWE hadn’t done something years similar years earlier like having a multi woman battle royal at Wrestlemania 23. and having a guy in drag win it.

      It cheapened something that was a big deal and of course wasn’t necessary.

  23. Darryl Stewart says:

    “Burn It Down” and being The Architect do make sense together in a way–after all, what better way to create new opportunities to build things than by burning down the -existing- buildings? So long as you don’t get caught, of course…

  24. Cuthbert says:

    There are a fair number of wrong things with this list, and they don’t even come down to opinions.

    There is no problem with the name “Great Balls Of Fire” for a name. Not sure why anyone would ever turn on it like they did. The reception it got was fucking pathetic.

    Shane McMahon was gold in pretty much everything he did this year. If anything you have to be annoyed at WWE for having a not-quite-young-anymore non-wrestler being one of the top 5 people in the fed.

    Ziggler’s theme-stealing angle was awesome.

    The Bayley vs. Bliss kendo match was really, really good. Did people not actually watch it? It’s like people are basing the whole match around the flub of the stick falling, which didn’t even affect the match.

    You’re 100% right about the stupid chants the audience does. They are part of what makes so much of their shows unwatchable anymore. When I did see matches, I literally had to mute ring introductions.

    But, i do ask: Why did you not include how WWE don’t even understand how to use a camera properly anymore? I had to quit watching the weekly shows because it is literally unwatchable with their ridiculous filming “techniques.”

    I have to say that it is not a good sign when two of your biggest problems are not even related to actual wrestling or storylines.

    • Danielbryan22 says:

      Whether or not the Kendo Stick match was good or not is not really the point. The match is the checkpoint where Bayley is buried and is not longer a serious competitor, despite all the hopes for her a year earlier.

      And the match was balls anyway to be honest. Not an Alexa fan.

      • Guesy says:

        The checkpoint of Bayley getting buried was when she tried to stop Alexa from going for a countout loss during a match with Sasha only to get beat down by Bliss, with next one being the two weeks or so of having Bayley get caned by Alexa.

        The match itself was basically the finish line.

  25. KatieVictoriasSecret says:

    I can’t decide if ‘all things Bayley’ or ‘all things Bray Wyatt’ is going to get my Gooker vote this year. I love both wrestlers and both wrestlers have had booking that was utterly horrendous. Failing that, it’s gonna be Emmalina for me. Nothing makes me angrier bookingwise than watching money get flushed down the toilet week after week with no actual payoff.

  26. Thomas Moffatt says:

    Am I the only one who finds Sarah Logan mind-blowingly hot?

  27. AK says:

    For me personally, I think the entry I most disagree with is 45) The Bludgeon Brothers’ outfits.

    Yes Rowan’s attire does look like a palette swapped version of OG Kane’s but I think it suits him as does Harper’s garb does for him. I think putting their outfits as Wrestlecrap is being nitpicky. They look like two dudes who would like right at home on the show Vikings or even Game of Thrones. They definitely look bad-ass to me, which I trust was the creative direction they were going for.

    If they debuted with a completely different gimmick than their vignettes, such as the second coming of Brodus Clay (maybe they would be dancing Woolly Mammoths?), then that would be Wrestlecrap. Although I imagine Harper and Rowan would make it work, as the underrated talents that they are.

    Overall, I think the list is pretty spot on. Perhaps I would switch 1 and 2 though. As bad as the
    House of Horrors was and was expected to be even before it happened, it was the first of its kind. If the WWE tried to recreate 1991’s Chamber of Horror match, then it would have been easy to stick that at #1.

    There are many reasons why I think This is Your Life Bayley should be #1 (and will likely be my pick for the Gooker)

    -It’s been done before and shame on WWE for trying to make Alexa Bliss and Bayley go out there to recreate the magic that the Rock and Mankind did.

    -Having Alexa (The Heel) lead the segment served no purpose in getting herself over and just buried Bayley further. Especially when their match resulted in Alexa winning and Bayley basically proving Alexa right that she couldn’t be Hardcore. Sure I imagine WWE doesn’t want to tarnish the Huggable One’s image, but she’s already been buried so much, it really wouldn’t have made a difference.

    -It was painful to watch, not because of Alexa and Bayley’s performances (which were only bad considering what they were unfairly compared against), but there was no charm, no substance and it dragged on. Neither Woman benefited from it and here’s hoping no other “This is your Life” segments are ever green-lit. WWE took something memorial and gave their universe pure dreck.

    • KatieVictoriasSecret says:

      This hits on a lot of the reasons why it didn’t work, adding onto that is the fact that this batch of writers doesn’t seem to understand that the reason why the Rock/Mankind TIYL segment worked was because of the give and take between the characters. In the work, even though the Rock gets to verbally shoot that segment down, the audience is left liking Mankind because he was trying to make his tag partner happy – boom, everyone goes home over.

      The entire Alexa/Bayley feud just suffers for the lack of that big super hero comeback that Bayley needed to get over. There’s a way to push the trusting, nice, kid-friendly superhero babyface in a way that draws audience sympathy (see: WCW and Sting) but this wasn’t it.

  28. Deepthroat Ghoul says:

    Regarding #32 and #22, it is true that Alicia Fox as a solo artist is about as fun to watch as your dad/mum/uncle/aunt’s colonoscopy video.

    Also, #39 confirms it: Dasha Fuentes is the New Era version of Stephanie Wiand from the New Generation Era minus the BIG beaver teeth.

  29. Anthony "A-Log" LoGatto says:

    I might be the only one saying it, but I’m personally gonna miss you bashing the WWE for it’s faux-charity work. You know they’re doing it so the Government doesn’t ban them (and all wrestling) for the Benoit incident.

  30. fatherofmustard says:

    Every feud/storyline Alexa has been involved in sucks.

  31. Mitch Colburn says:

    Alexa Bliss carried RAW’s women’s division. Paige was hurt most of the year and suffered from bad booking on her return, Mickie James is booked horribly, Sasha sucks, Bayley fell flat, Nia Jax and Dana Brooke are beyond awful, Asuka is boring…Alexa’s the one bright spot on RAW in terms of female competitors.

  32. Acolyte Of Glorious La Parka~, King & Master Of Men And Lover Of Women says:

    The whole “Under Siege” bullsh*t was HORRIBLE. Suddenly RAW and SMACKDOWN blood enemies are willing allies to beat up the opposing show’s roster, where THEIR blood enemies are suddenly allies? EASY number 2 worst moment of above.

    But, for Number 1, NOTHING beats Bayley’s destruction. The Foley-Rock “This Is Your Life” ripoff was SO bad, even I, who can watch practically ANY WWE garbage and still be somewhat entertained, couldn’t watch that excrable s**t without experiencing severe physical pain. I watched Katie Vick and Mae Young’s hand birth, and THIS was immeasurably even worse then THOSE. And then they FURTHER ended Bayley’s career with that abortion of a following match. Bayley’s career is now officially deader than Undertaker, and THIS is what killed it. Hell, she’s getting booed out of every building she’s in now, and the sad thing is it’s NOT her fault. Vince destroys ANOTHER potentially great NXT’er’s career (remember the Ascenction? Neither do I).

    At least Haitch KNOWS how to market a potentially great future star. Let’s hope that Vince somehow gets out soon and Paul takes over.

  33. TheGreat31 says:

    My Gran, 85 years old, watches WWE every single week, turned to me one night and asked, in all seriousness:

    “Why does Seth Rollins’ music yell ‘Bernie Downs’ now?”

  34. DracoDracul says:

    Does anyone else sometimes feel that NXT exists less to development new talent for the main roster and more to make up for the lack of major competition? I mean now Vince can bring in promising talent and bury them in humiliating ways just like in the good old days.

  35. Cecigi says:

    IMHO We had no reason to want to see Noam Dar and Alicia Fox back together again, because he was very right to dump her.

leave a comment